Stable

CF28 Record Retention: When Can Files Be Destroyed?

Reis Renneker

Written by Reis Renneker

CF28 support generally must remain available for five years after the response date, even when CBP issues a favorable determination.

CF28 Record Retention: When Can Files Be Destroyed?

A favorable CBP decision does not necessarily close the file for recordkeeping purposes. CF28 record retention generally continues for five years from the response activity, making the response date, supporting evidence, and internal decision trail critical elements of an importer’s customs compliance program.

How the Five-Year CF28 Retention Period Works

The general customs recordkeeping framework under 19 CFR 163.4 requires covered records to be retained for five years. When a record relates directly to an entry, the period generally begins on the date of entry. When a later customs activity requires a new record to be created, the five-year period generally begins on the date of that activity.

A CBP Form 28 request for information is a separate compliance activity. The importer’s response, including the documents assembled to support that response, creates an additional recordkeeping event. As a result, the retention period for the CF28 response package may extend beyond the retention period calculated from the original entry date.

The Response Date Generally Controls the New Period

Consider an entry filed on January 1, 2026. CBP issues a CF28 on August 1, 2026, and the importer responds on September 1, 2026. The original entry records may have a retention period measured from January 1, but the response package generally must remain available until September 1, 2031.

The same activity-based principle may apply to later records generated through CBP Form 29 actions, protests, supplemental submissions, or other post-entry proceedings. Each event should be evaluated separately rather than grouped under the original entry date.

A Positive Determination Does Not End the Obligation

A favorable classification, origin, valuation, or admissibility determination does not ordinarily shorten the recordkeeping period. It resolves the immediate inquiry, but the records may still be relevant to an audit, later review, related entries, or an internal compliance assessment.

Importers should therefore avoid treating the date of CBP’s favorable decision as permission to destroy the file. The safer operational approach is to identify the latest activity that required record creation and calculate the applicable retention date from that event.

What Should Be Included in the CF28 Record

A defensible CF28 file should contain more than the final response letter. It should preserve the complete factual and analytical record needed to demonstrate what CBP requested, how the importer interpreted the request, what evidence was provided, and how the matter was resolved.

Depending on the issue, the supporting package may include commercial invoices, purchase orders, bills of material, technical specifications, product literature, manufacturing records, certificates of origin, transportation documents, valuation calculations, classification analyses, contracts, payment records, and correspondence with suppliers or customs brokers.

Preserve the Request, Response, and Decision Trail

At a minimum, the file should generally contain:

  • The complete CBP Form 28, including all instructions and attachments
  • Evidence of the date the request was received
  • The final response and proof of submission
  • Every document submitted with the response
  • Internal analyses and approvals supporting material conclusions
  • Relevant communications with the broker, supplier, counsel, or other parties
  • Follow-up questions and supplemental submissions
  • CBP’s final determination or other closing communication
  • Any corrective actions applied to later entries

The file should also identify the affected entry numbers, products, tariff classifications, countries of origin, suppliers, and business units. This indexing allows compliance teams to locate related records quickly if CBP expands an inquiry beyond a single transaction.

Classification and Origin Files May Have Continuing Value

A product classification or origin analysis can remain operationally relevant after the minimum CF28 retention period expires. If the importer continues entering the same merchandise under the same position, retaining the underlying rationale may support consistent filing and future review.

That does not mean every record must be held indefinitely. It means the legal retention schedule and the business value of a continuing compliance file should be evaluated separately. A classification database, ruling file, or origin methodology may warrant a longer lifecycle than transaction-specific supporting documents.

Why ACE Should Not Be the Only Archive

ACE is an essential source of entry and post-entry information, but it should not be treated as the importer’s complete CF28 document repository. System access, report content, attachment availability, user permissions, and historical data presentation may not reproduce the full record assembled when the response was prepared.

Certain instructions, attachments, internal analyses, supplier communications, and supporting documents may never appear in an ACE report. Even when a submission is visible, the system record may not preserve the context needed to explain why particular evidence was selected or how the importer reached its conclusion.

The Importer Retains Its Own Recordkeeping Responsibility

Customs brokers often maintain substantial entry documentation, but the importer should not assume that the broker’s archive satisfies every internal or regulatory obligation. Contracts, system migrations, personnel changes, and account transitions can affect future access. Responsibility for preserving required records generally remains with the party subject to the applicable requirement.

A sound control environment therefore maintains an independent, searchable CF28 file linked to the affected entries. The archive should preserve document versions, submission dates, responsible personnel, and final outcomes. Access controls should prevent unauthorized alteration while allowing timely retrieval during an audit or enforcement inquiry.

Electronic Conversion Requires Documented Controls

Paper records may often be converted into an acceptable electronic format, provided the organization’s process preserves complete, accurate, legible, and retrievable copies. Before destroying paper originals, the company should confirm that electronic retention is permitted for the document type and that no original-document requirement, litigation hold, investigation, or contractual obligation applies.

Quality checks should verify that every page, attachment, annotation, stamp, and signature was captured. The company should also test retrieval, backup, security, and export procedures. Scanning a document is not enough if the resulting image cannot be found, authenticated, or produced in a usable form years later.

Building a Defensible Destruction Policy

Document destruction should occur under a written retention policy, not through individual judgment. The policy should define record categories, triggering events, minimum retention periods, responsible owners, approved storage formats, legal hold procedures, and documented destruction methods.

For CF28 matters, a schedule based only on the original entry date can produce premature deletion. The records management system should allow the retention clock to be updated when a CF28 response, supplemental submission, CBP decision, protest, or other activity creates a later recordkeeping date.

Use Matter-Level Retention Dates

Each inquiry should have a matter-level closing record showing the relevant dates and the calculated destruction date. A practical workflow typically includes:

  1. Recording the CF28 receipt date and response deadline.
  2. Linking the inquiry to every potentially affected entry.
  3. Preserving the exact request and all attachments.
  4. Capturing each response and supplemental submission date.
  5. Recording CBP’s decision and any required corrective action.
  6. Calculating retention from the latest applicable activity.
  7. Checking for legal holds or continuing business use before destruction.
  8. Documenting final deletion or physical destruction.

Automated deletion rules should be suspended whenever an audit, investigation, protest, disclosure, litigation hold, or related review is pending. The organization should also consider whether a determination affects later entries. If it does, the underlying analysis may need to remain active even after the original response package reaches the end of its minimum period.

Apply the Policy Consistently

Selective destruction can create avoidable compliance and litigation risks. The same schedule should generally apply across business units, storage locations, email systems, shared drives, broker portals, and paper archives. Periodic testing should confirm that records are both retained for the required period and destroyed when authorized.

A disciplined policy reduces unnecessary storage while preserving evidence that supports reasonable care. It also helps customs teams respond efficiently when CBP asks whether a prior determination was applied consistently across subsequent imports.

Recent Developments
  • No regulatory changes to 19 CFR 163.4 record retention periods were identified in the past 30 days.* The general 5-year rule from the date of entry (or from the date of the activity that created the record, such as a CF28 response) continues to apply, meaning supporting documents for a CF28 with a positive determination should generally be retained for 5 years from the response date.
  • On October 8, 2026, a detailed industry analysis of 19 CFR 163.4 reiterated that records created by a customs activity (explicitly including those supporting CF28 classification or other inquiries) must be kept for 5 years from the date of that activity, which resets the clock independently of the original entry date. Classification rationale files in particular may need to persist longer if the product continues to be imported.
  • CBP issued an Interim Final Rule on November 6, 2026 (effective January 5, 2027) on heightened requirements for foreign importers of record. Brokers must now request, review, and retain client verification records (such as ownership, citizenship, or financial documents) for 5 years from the verification date, adding new 5-year obligations that could intersect with entry-related CF28 activity.
  • Industry reports from October 17 and November 11, 2026 describe a noticeable increase in CF28 issuances (often pattern-based rather than single-entry) since late 2025, with CBP requesting extensive supporting materials such as bills of material, manufacturing capability records, invoices, and origin proofs. Practitioners advise keeping these organized and retrievable to support timely responses.
  • No recent practitioner discussions on X specifically addressed CF28 document destruction versus retention or ACE historical access. Existing ICPA forum guidance (the source of the original question) aligns with the 5-year activity-based clock and company document retention policies. ACE may hold some CBP-side history, but importers remain responsible for their own supporting records.
1 2 3

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Should Supporting Documents for a CF28 Response Be Retained?

Supporting documents should generally be retained for five years from the date of the response or other activity that required their creation. If supplemental responses are submitted later, the organization should evaluate whether the latest submission creates a later retention date for some or all of the matter file.

Can CF28 Records Be Destroyed After a Favorable Determination?

Not immediately. A favorable determination does not ordinarily eliminate the five-year recordkeeping obligation. Destruction should occur only after the applicable period has expired and after confirming that no investigation, legal hold, related protest, continuing import activity, or internal policy requires longer retention.

Is the Five-Year Period Measured From the Entry Date or Response Date?

Entry records are generally measured from the entry date. Records created because of a later CF28 activity are generally measured from the date of that activity. For the response package, the response date will typically establish the relevant five-year period, although later submissions may require separate analysis.

Can an Importer Rely on ACE to Preserve the Complete CF28 History?

ACE should not be the sole archive. It may provide important entry and communication history, but it may not contain every attachment, specific instruction, internal analysis, supplier record, or contextual communication. Importers should maintain their own complete and searchable files.

May Paper CF28 Documents Be Destroyed After Scanning?

Paper destruction may be appropriate when a compliant electronic copy is complete, legible, accurate, secure, and readily retrievable. Before destruction, the importer should confirm that originals are not required and that no legal hold or other obligation applies. The scanning and quality-control process should be documented.

Should Classification Support Be Kept Longer Than Five Years?

In some cases, yes. A classification analysis may continue to support entries made after the CF28 matter closes. Importers should distinguish the minimum retention period for a particular response from the operational need to preserve a current classification rationale for merchandise that remains in the import program.

How Stable Software Can Help

Support Stronger Broker-Led Compliance Workflows

Customs brokers need reliable processes for connecting entry data, post-entry activity, and client documentation. Stable Software provides DrawbackAI for customs brokers, which brokers can white-label for importer clients and use to file duty drawback claims under their own filer code.

DrawbackAI is offered through a flat software license. Stable Software does not take a percentage of the importer’s refund. This structure allows brokers to maintain the client relationship and control the filing process while expanding their duty drawback capabilities. Brokers evaluating how software fits into a broader customs compliance and recordkeeping strategy can explore the platform and its broker-focused model.

Resources

TypeResource
SourcePrimary source

✉️

Sign up for our newsletter

A monthly post on trade, tariffs, and customs, delivered straight to your inbox.